Search

Book Review: A Woman's Lot (The Meonbridge Chronicles, Book 2) by Carolyn Hughes



Publication Date: 28th September 2019 Publisher: Riverdown Books Page Length: 340 Pages Genre: Historical Fiction

How can mere women resist the misogyny of men?


1352. In Meonbridge, a resentful peasant rages against Eleanor Titherige’s efforts to build up her flock of sheep. Susanna Miller’s husband, grown melancholy and ill-tempered, succumbs to idle gossip that his wife’s a scold. Agnes Sawyer’s yearning to be a craftsman is met with scorn. And the village priest, fearful of what he considers women’s “unnatural” ambitions, is determined to keep them firmly in their place.

Many men hold fast to the teachings of the Church and fear the havoc the “daughters of Eve” might wreak if they’re allowed to usurp men’s roles and gain control over their own lives.


Not all men in Meonbridge resist the women’s desire for change – indeed, they want it for themselves. Yet it takes only one or two misogynists to unleash the hounds of hostility and hatred…



“What’s this I just heard,’ roared Will, ‘’bout you stealing Missus Titherige’s sheep?’ ”


It had seemed like a good idea at the time, and it wasn’t as if Eleanor Titherige was going to notice that three ewes were missing from her flock.


Unfortunately for Luke and his young and somewhat simple cousin, Arthur, Eleanor and her shepherd, Walter, did indeed notice that they were missing. Eleanor is determined to find her missing sheep, not only because they belong to her, but because she fears for their welfare as all three are heavily pregnant.

When the missing sheep are finally found, it is too late to save them, for the boys had failed in the most basic of animal husbandries.


In these troubled times, one could expect no leniency for theft. If one could not pay the compensation to the aggrieved party, they would pay by losing a limb, or in a worst-case scenario, it would result in the thief dancing from the end of a rope. Luke is determined to avoid arrest, and so he flees with his young cousin into the woods. But it will only be a matter of time before the authorities find them…


From a devious and ill-conceived plan to steal some sheep to a shocking truth told in front of a jury, A Woman’s Lot (The Meonbridge Chronicles, Book 2) by Carolyn Hughes is, in all ways, a Historical Fiction triumph.


Having read Fortune’s Wheel (The Meonbridge Chronicles, Book 1), it was with an eager anticipation that I began to read Book 2. I expected big things from this novel because Hughes is an accomplished writer who has a gift for bringing the past vividly back to life. Hughes’ compelling narrative and her striking portrayal of a hard-up and, for the most part, hard-working community, made this book not only utterly compelling from beginning to end but also one that is shamelessly enthralling. I am not ashamed to admit that this book exceeded all my expectations. I did not read this story. I lived it!


The story is set in the village of Meonbridge, whose occupants had been ravaged by the Black Death and are now trying most desperately to put back the pieces of their shattered hearts. For some, life will never be the same again, whereas for others, despite the heartache of loss, this was an opportunity to become more, to earn more, and to, despite the aristocracy’s thoughts on the matter, finally have more of a say on how they lived and how much they were paid.


Unlike most novels set during this era, we do not read the story from the aristocracy’s perspective, although Sir Richard and Lady Margaret du Bohun do make several cameo appearances. Instead, this novel tells the story from the perspective of the common folk—the cottars, the millers, the carpenters and the shepherds. More surprising still, this story does, for the most part, follow the lives of three very different women.


Many women were left widowed, and their children snatched away from them because of the Death, but those who survived had to find a way to make the best of it and carry on. This unwavering determination to push forward make all three women whose story we follow in this novel intensely gripping. Eleanor Titherigh lost everyone to the Death, bar her step-brother, and now she is determined to raise a fine flock of sheep. Agnus Sawyer wants to learn her husband’s trade; she is convinced that she could learn to be a carpenter and make the most splendid things out of wood as her husband does. Susanna Miller, however, would have loved to help her husband run the mill, even if it were just keeping the books, but her husband will have none of it, and even Agnus’ husband was having second thoughts about letting his wife work alongside him. Could it be because of the sermons of Master Hugo Garret? Garret does nothing to hide his contempt and hatred of the fairer sex, and as he is a man of God, then what he preaches must be true. Hughes has brought this vast array of very different characters to life with a bold and successful sweep of her quill, and the story she has told is quite simply unputdownable.


This novel’s historical setting has clearly been painstakingly researched, but Hughes also has an empathetic understanding of human nature. The indoctrination of men such as Henry Miller and Jack Sawyer by the misogynist priest was really unsettling, as was their treatment of their wives as they began to listen to the evils of a man who claimed to be speaking God’s word. Likewise, with Jack, he also listens to master craftsman, who claim that a woman could not possibly become skilled in a craft such as theirs. For woman such as Angus, this is terribly upsetting, for she feels as if she has failed as a mother and a wife, but also she feels as if she has failed herself. She is forced to give up the craft she enjoyed but she is still being judged unfairly because she has difficulty keeping control of her boisterous young children. As is often the case in societies that belittle and demean women, there really is no chance of escape.


To make matters worse, there are those who thrive on gossip. There are women who smile to your face and whisper falsehoods behind your back because they have nothing better to do with their sad, pathetic lives. I have always found it very difficult to understand what makes such people tick. Some delight in destroying another’s character without regret or thought, but on the flip side, there are women in this novel like Eleanor who wants Luke and Arthur to be called to account for their crimes, but she does not want them to hang for it either. She is conflicted, as many women in this novel are.


Hughes also depicts the injustice of the justice system during this era. Court cases could be hurried along and the right whisper in the right ear did, in some cases, ensure a biased verdict. I was also surprised that those accused of a crime could be held in a cell for years before their case was brought towards the King’s Justice. It was a very sobering thought.


The Meonbridge Chronicles is as mesmerising as Winston Graham’s Poldark series. There is injustice, poverty, but also hope and romance. I could have very easily read another thousand pages, and my attention would not have wavered. This is a series that deserves to be read and enjoyed. It is certainly deserving of a place upon your bookshelf.


I Highly Recommend.


Review by Mary Anne Yarde. The Coffee Pot Book Club.



Amazon UKAmazon US




Carolyn Hughes was born in London, but has lived most of her life in Hampshire. After a first degree in Classics and English, she started her working life as a computer programmer, in those days a very new profession. It was fun for a few years, but she left to become a school careers officer in Dorset.

But it was when she discovered technical authoring that she knew she had found her vocation. She spent the next few decades writing and editing all sorts of material, some fascinating, some dull, for a wide variety of clients, including an international hotel group, medical instrument manufacturers and the Government.

She has written creatively for most of her adult life, but it was not until her children grew up and flew the nest, several years ago, that creative writing and, especially, writing historical fiction, took centre stage in her life.

She has a Masters in Creative Writing from Portsmouth University, and a PhD from the University of Southampton.

Connect with Carolyn: Website TwitterInstagramGoodreads.